Macho Politics Defined Trump's Presidency, Culminating With Capitol Riot
In President Trump's Jan. 6 speech ahead of the riot on Capitol Hill, there was a telling moment that was easy to miss amid his calls to "fight like hell." It was when Trump went on a tangent about the Republican governor of Georgia, one of the states Trump is angry he did not win on Election Day.
"And I had Brian Kemp, who weighs 130 pounds," Trump told the crowd. "He said he played offensive line in football. I'm trying to figure that out. I'm still trying to figure that out. He said that the other night: 'I was an offensive lineman.' I'm saying: 'Really? That must have been a very small team.'"
The crowd laughed appreciatively.
For however random and rambling that may have seemed, it nevertheless fit into the speech perfectly: the president belittling an opponent as weak while portraying himself and his supporters as strong. Weakness, it turned out, was a major theme in that speech, with the president wielding it in particular against his fellow Republicans.
"We got to get rid of the weak congresspeople, the ones that aren't any good, the Liz Cheneys of the world," he said, calling out the House Republican Conference Chair who would ultimately, days later, vote for his impeachment. "We got to get rid of them."
It wasn't just this speech. Amid all the chaos of the Trump presidency, he has been unfailingly consistent in his fixation on being a tough guy — one with a very particular, combative form of masculinity.
It has shown up everywhere in his political career from petty insults, referring to primary opponents as "lil' Marco" and "low-energy Jeb," to encouraging violence against protesters at his rallies.
That macho presidency culminated with a riot on Capitol Hill that left five dead. The crowd was not only overwhelmingly white, but majority-male, according to observers.
A "not totally unpredictable" riot
"The events at the Capitol, while they were dramatic and outrageous, they were not totally unpredictable," said Jackson Katz, author and creator of the film The Man Card, about white male identity politics.
In his opinion, while race has been central to Trump's political strategy, gender is also inextricable.
"What he's been signaling is not just that he's the white person who's going to stand up for white civilization, if you will, but he's a white man who's tough, who doesn't back down and who's strong, who embodies a certain kind of masculine gravitas and strength," Katz said.
Many Trump supporters' rhetoric mirrors this. Before Trump even became president, some of his supporters in the so-called "alt-right" referred to Republicans whom they deemed insufficiently hardline as "cucks" and "cuckservatives." That word is a portmanteau of "conservative" and "cuckold."
Trump backers in Washington seemed to understand the types of masculine compliments Trump craved. When Trump was diagnosed with coronavirus, Florida Republican Rep. Matt Gaetz tweeted: "President Trump won't have to recover from COVID. COVID will have to recover from President Trump."
President Trump won't have to recover from COVID.— Rep. Matt Gaetz (@RepMattGaetz) October 5, 2020
COVID will have to recover from President Trump. #MAGA
In fact, the days since the riot have provided still new evidence of Trump's preoccupation with his gender. Former chief of staff John Kelly told a Des Moines audience that Trump can't admit to mistakes because "his manhood is at issue here," as The Des Moines Register's Donnelle Ellers reported.
In pressuring Vice President Mike Pence to help him overturn the results of the election, Trump reportedly resorted to a misogynistic vulgarity. "You can either go down in history as a patriot, or you can go down in history as a pussy," Trump said according to the New York Times.
Masculine ideals predict Trump support
The strong link between performative masculinity and the Trump presidency is not just anecdotal. There is a growing body of scholarly evidence of the links between gender attitudes and Trump support: for example, in a newly published study from Terri Vescio and Nathaniel Schermerhorn at Penn State University.
"Our main finding was that people who endorse 'hegemonic masculinity,' or the idea that men should be powerful, high status, tough and nothing like women, the people who endorse these ideals were more likely to support Trump," Vescio said. "And that was for men and women over and above gender, over and above political orientation, and regardless of level of education."
Again, that was for men and women, meaning that it's not surprising that women were among the rioters. In one widely shared video, Texan Jenny Cudd bragged about her part in the riots.
"We did break down [House Speaker] Nancy Pelosi's office door and somebody stole her gavel, and took a picture sitting in the chair flipping off the camera, and that was on Fox News," she said.
The idealization of a particular type of masculinity has gone hand in hand with hostility to women. Research has also found a link between "hostile sexism" and Trump support. In addition, numerous reports since the Capitol Hill riot have cited misogynist language among the rioters toward women leaders like Pelosi and Washington, D.C., Mayor Muriel Bowser.
One man, Richard Barnett of Arkansas, was photographed sitting at Pelosi's desk and later bragged about stealing a piece of her mail.
"I wrote her a nasty note, put my feet up on her desk and scratched my balls," he told the New York Times' Matthew Rosenberg.
Trump's broad appeal to voters and the way that he emboldens right-wing extremists reflect broader global political trends, in the opinion of Soraya Chemaly, executive director of the Representation Project, a nonprofit that fights gender inequality.
"I think there's a lot going on. I think that one thing is that there is a global tide of macho fascism and masculinist backlash against change," she said. "And I think that what we saw in the rise of Trump was part of that tide."
Trump benefited from and amped up existing political and cultural attitudes about gender, in short, meaning that as he leaves office, those ideas won't go away. In addition, Chemaly stressed, attitudes about gender are tightly woven together with those about race, class and party.
For now, Trump and his team are trying to burnish his masculine image as he leaves office. This was highlighted when Fox News' Bill Hemmer asked Trump campaign spokesman Hogan Gidley last week about Trump's feelings in the fallout from the riot.
Fox News Anchor Bill Hemmer asks Trump National Press Secretary Hogan Gidley if the president feels emasculated from "the social media crackdown." pic.twitter.com/lIirtRXWhN— The Recount (@therecount) January 11, 2021
"With the social media crackdown, does he feel emasculated?" Hemmer said.
"Look. I wouldn't say emasculated," Gidley said. "The most masculine person to ever hold the White House is the president of the United States."
It was one of the most salient aspects of the Trump presidency, captured in one unsubtle question and one unsubtle response.
Copyright 2021 NPR. To see more, visit https://www.npr.org.